Aside from Alice Prospero from the movies, with her canon defying psychic powers from the t-Virus and Kung Fu Fighting the Nemesis without becoming a bloodspatter and human paste on the ground? And how the narrative makes her the only competent character when on-screen? *cough*
I’d say Chris Redfield, in the game canon. (In the movie canon, he seems to be an expy of Billy, strangely enough.) And, yes, I realize I just committed fandom blasphemy. And, yes, I loathe him. :|
Okay, hear me out here. I do have reasons for saying I hate him and calling him a Gary Stu. It’s not like that crap where some moron was saying how Claire as useless and sucked and Jill was the best person ever, but didn’t give any reasons for why they said that.
Chris Redfield, as a whole, no matter what shit he pulls, seems to be treated as the hero of the story. This becomes irksome when one remembers 2 and Code: Veronica. The original reason why Claire got involved with either incident was because she was looking for Chris. Chris ran off, and as even the Dark Id (a Let’s Player who did an LP of Code: Veronica) spelled out in his walkthrough, the whole story of Code: Veronica could have been prevented by a 10 minute phone call.
Now, the reason why this bothers me is that Chris ran off and it’s handwaved in the story that he didn’t say a word of anything to his family, so they wouldn’t follow him and end up in danger. But Code: Veronica and the fandom both imply that he’s very close to Claire. If that’s true, why the hell didn’t he expect her to try searching for him once he disappeared?
(I can’t say anything about Revelations and Chris disappearing there, namely due to how it was O’Brian and Raymond manipulating the entire situation off the ship and on, respectively.)
Much like Agent Mulder in The X-Files (and this sort of pattern does bother me in the show, though I do like it), throughout the course of RE5, Chris has this half-baked theory. Said half-baked theory is that Jill is alive. His reason: A blurry, tiny, strangely angled, and tinted-in-various shades-of-green photo of a blonde woman in a tube. Chris and Sheva then disobey their direct orders and, guess what? Chris somehow turns out to be right, despite him thinking Jill was dead for three years.
The same sort of pattern actually shows up earlier in RE2 and RE3. More specifically, Jill’s Diary and Chris’s Diary both elaborate on what happened after the events of RE1 that lead up to both games and Chris vanishing. Chris automatically hones in that Umbrella is planning something and he runs off to Europe on a lead. In Jill’s Diary, it says that Chris was talking about the G Virus. (Curiously, he says that he received help from Jill and Barry about finding out about the G-Virus, but Jill says that she knew nothing of it until after Chris told her.)
You also come across a fax in RE2 from the FBI about the G Virus. Even they know nothing about it! They do know that Irons is dangerous and try to warn Chris about him, though, so I am skeptical of there being a cover up of some sort. [Irons was part of the Umbrella cover-up in Raccoon City, so making Chris wary of someone trying to cover the whole mess up would make no sense, if one were to assume the FBI was somehow involved in trying to cover Umbrella’s shit up.]
But he heard a rumor about the G Virus and happened to turn out to be correct.
*sarcasm* Yup, that makes perfect sense. The guy who is onto Umbrella and Umbrella wants to hush up has better access to Umbrella records than the FBI. *end sarcasm*
All of these factors viewed together remind me of this article by Kit Whitfield about the Macho Sue. It notes that, among other things, quote, “As a result, from an objective viewpoint, Macho Sue doesn’t have to make any effort to do the right thing; he can act on his impulses and the right thing follows him around like a loyal little dog, herding the rest of the story into place.”
That is precisely what happens with Chris. No matter how radical or idiotic his conclusions seem, no matter how off-the-wall batshit insane he sounds, no matter how many leaps in logic he makes, he’s right.
What makes it even worse is that Claire does the same exact thing (jumping to conclusions about what’s going on) and it’s treated realistically! She jumps to conclusions about Chris being in Raccoon City and that bites her in the ass as she gets involved in the Raccoon City incident. She then jumps to conclusions about Chris’s location and heads to Paris. That bites her in the ass again and she then gets caught up in the events of Code: Veronica.
And this is why I like Parker, Quint, Keith, Raymond, Claire, Jill, the Outbreak cast, etc. much better than Chris. They have flaws. They are vulnerable to attack. Their fates are less concrete than Chris.
But RE6 does give me hope, at least, that they’ll maybe treat him as having flaws and have him fuck up and be WRONG for once. Knowing my luck, though, that won’t happen and Leon will be treated like the bad guy for standing up to Chris and trying to call him out on his bullshit of “randomly jumping the gun and thinking he’s always right.” But that didn’t work, when Sheva tried calling Chris out about Jill and they pressed onward anyway (“That woman in the data file? Are you even sure it’s the same person!?”), so Leon would really have to stand his ground. :\
This doesn’t mean that the people who roleplay as Chris and Alice make them a GS/MS respectively. They have to keep things more realistic, lest be called out on godmodding. Hell, there’s no guarantee that other writers won’t call them out, anyway. And, what’s dubbed a “Possession Sue” by TvTropes can occur (taking a canon character that wasn’t a Sue/Stu and turning them into one in fanfiction and roleplaying).
A character, this time in fanfiction, that gets the GS treatment a lot seems to be Steve Burnside, when he isn’t being horridly demonized by the fanatical kind of Cleon shippers. It’s rather painful, because he’s not a suave person and his infection wouldn’t necessarily be the most stable, but they treat him as though his infection has no downsides (despite how he mutates into a giant monster nicknamed “Stevezilla” by a portion of the fandom).
I’m starting to wonder why you’re asking about this, anon? Not that I don’t mind answering, just curious.